How to Close a Collage Journal That Has Become Too Thick

Why collage makes a journal resist closing

A blank journal is built around a particular text block: its pages, folds, spine, and covers work together as a structure. Each attached scrap, folded flap, raised decoration, or thick layer of adhesive adds depth, often unevenly. That can make one section much thicker than the rest, leaving the covers unable to meet without pressure. The Northeast Document Conservation Center (NEDCC) describes added scraps as a cause of bulging and undue stress in scrapbook bindings; the Library of Congress likewise recommends keeping scrapbook size and weight modest. NEDCC, “Storage and Handling for Books and Artifacts on Paper”, Library of Congress, “Preservation Measures for Scrapbooks and Albums”

The key diagnostic is not just total thickness but where it sits. A journal that is evenly plump may behave differently from one with a few thick clusters near the front or back. This is a practical inference from how added material bulges bindings and how uneven pressure can affect stored paper objects; it is not a universal repair formula.

Inspect the journal without stressing the binding

Set the journal on a clear, flat surface and let the covers rest in their natural position. Do not force it fully open or closed. Look at it from the side and compare the fore edge (the page edges opposite the spine) with the spine edge. Notice whether the covers tilt apart evenly or whether a few pages make a distinct bump. Check for loose items trapped between pages, bulky folded pockets, thick layered scraps, and decorations that catch on the facing leaf.

Turn pages slowly, supporting the whole leaf as you go, especially when a page is heavy with additions. The Library of Congress advises against forcing a scrapbook flat and recommends supporting heavy leaves; the National Archives also advises handling bound volumes without forcing them beyond their natural flex. Library of Congress, National Archives, “Bound Materials”

Watch for warning signs: a widening gap between a cover and the pages, stitching that has loosened, a cracked or detached spine, pages tearing near the binding, or collage pieces lifting when you turn a leaf. Those signs suggest the structure is already under strain. Stop manipulating the affected area. If the journal has strong personal value, or the attachment is delicate, ask a book or paper conservator before removing anything; adhesive-backed layers can tear the page or disturb material beneath them.

Reduce thickness by changing only what is safely removable

Start with items that are loose rather than peeling attached collage away. Remove bookmarks, unglued inserts, and other pieces that can be lifted out without tugging. Keep them in order in a labeled envelope or folder beside the journal, and note the page or spread they came from. This preserves the association while taking unnecessary bulk out of the binding. NEDCC advises removing ephemeral inserts when possible to reduce binding strain, and keeping track of pieces stored separately if there are too many to leave in the book safely. NEDCC

Next, identify additions you can detach without disturbing the page or neighboring materials. For a casual journal, that might mean a removable paper pocket or a loose card. If something is firmly glued, catches on another page, or is part of a layered composition, do not treat “remove bulk” as a reason to pry it off. The National Archives warns that removing records from scrapbook pages can be difficult without damage and advises leaving contents in place when safe removal is uncertain. Its instructions address archival material, but the underlying caution about attached layers applies here too. National Archives

Avoid squeezing the closed journal under heavy objects, binding it tightly with elastic, or adding tape or glue to the spine as a quick fix. Pressure may flatten raised collage unevenly and transfer stress to the hinge or page attachments; a tight tie can also harm a binding. If it cannot close under its own weight, let it rest open only as far as it naturally allows, supported on both sides, or store it flat in a box large enough to accommodate its actual thickness. NEDCC recommends flat storage for scrapbooks and cautions that overly tight ties can damage bindings.

Choose a storage position that fits its current shape

A journal that no longer closes neatly does not have to be forced shut for storage. Place it flat, with its whole surface supported. Avoid stacking other books or objects on top, since that adds pressure to the thickest areas. NEDCC recommends storing scrapbooks horizontally, singly or in stacks of two, and measuring any protective box at the binding’s thickest point. The National Archives similarly notes that an overfilled scrapbook may be too bulky to close tightly and recommends flat storage in a box to protect contents. NEDCC, National Archives

For an everyday journal, a clean, rigid container with enough room to avoid crushing raised pages can serve as a simple protective home. Do not make the fit so tight that inserting or removing the journal catches the cover or collage. If pieces are loose, keep them in separate labeled enclosures rather than slipping bulky sleeves or folders between bound pages; added enclosures can create more strain. The National Archives specifically warns that inserts and sleeves can stress a binding when they add too much thickness. National Archives

Make future collage pages thinner and more even

To keep the journal usable, spread dimensional work across more pages instead of building one thick cluster. Use fewer overlapping layers in any single spread, choose flatter paper for large background areas, and reserve raised embellishments for occasional focal points. This is a practical design inference: if added scraps create bulging and stress, distributing additions and reducing their depth should limit local bulk. It is not a guarantee that a particular journal can support a specific amount.

Treat bulky pockets, folded elements, and loose memorabilia as inserts you can store separately. You can label a small envelope with the date or spread and keep it in a box with the journal, adding a brief note in the book to preserve the connection. When choosing or making a journal for ongoing collage, an expandable structure may suit additions better; the Library of Congress cites expandable album formats as one option for long-lasting scrapbooks. Library of Congress

Build in a pause before adding another thick item: set it on the intended page and close the covers gently without pressing. If the covers immediately spring apart or the page makes a pronounced high spot, choose a flatter version, move the item to a separate enclosure, or use another journal designed for more volume. This simple check helps you respond before repeated additions compound the pressure.

When to ask for conservation help

If the spine is cracked, the cover hinge is separating, stitching is breaking, or attached collage cannot be removed without tearing, stop trying to repair it with household tape or glue. A binding repair or a redesigned housing may be needed. Yale University Library notes that conservators sometimes stabilize bindings, support pages, and add spine spacers to compensate for overstuffed contents—specialist treatments, not a reason to wedge material into a casual journal yourself. Yale University Library, “Caring for Yale Library’s Albums and Scrapbooks”

For a personal journal that remains usable, the least disruptive sequence is straightforward: inspect the bulk, remove only loose or safely detachable extras, store the book flat without pressure, and reduce the thickness of future additions. Let the binding set the limit. Your collage can remain part of the journal’s story without asking the spine and pages to carry every keepsake inside the covers.

Keep exploring this topic